Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jesse Damiani's avatar

All great points, thank you! Critical stuff to consider. I’ll direct folks this way in the post so that they can read them.

Expand full comment
Constantin's avatar

1Password travel mode is not a panacea. It’s a feature that might help while making other tradeoffs.

It is true that you can use 1Password v8 to effectively travel “clean” through customs, with no password data on you. But that too will raise suspicions, just like the kids who thought they could either selectively delete their social media or pretend that they have no social media accounts at all.

Secondly, 1Password v8 forces you to store all your passwords in a cloud system that Agilebits claims is secure. Version 7 and below allowed the user a choice of where to store the encrypted data file and how to exchange updates among devices - in a cloud or locally.

The cloud storage requirement was a cornerstone to the subscription-only model that agilebits rolled out as of v8. In the before times, people could buy perpetual licenses. To me, v8 is a classic example of a “enshittified” app where valuable features are removed while price is raised.

The cloud model is predicated on encryption being secure, their implementation being secure, etc. and it represents a huge target for hackers. It’s available 24/7, lots of reward for the effort put in since 1Password users can also use it to store SSNs, photo ID, and like sensitive documents.

Whereas the local storage model of prior versions would require a hacker to hack into millions of homes (which will not scale as easily since people have choices re firewalls, OS, IDS, and so on). Ditto local exchange vs. cloud exchange. It’s very hard to scale intercepting stuff locally for an attacker.

So no, I would not put 1Password v8 on a pedestal. Instead, I would travel with a password manager that has a minimum of content (ie a travel subset that you cannot be without) while leaving the rest behind. Ideally travel with burner devices that have little content to go through in the first place.

On iOS / MacOs consider strongbox pro as an excellent alternative to 1Password, it gives you a choice where to store passwords and how to exchange them among devices. They even offer family plans and give you a choice between perpetual licenses and subscriptions. I know, choice, what a concept.

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts